Waiver Method

So the next thing we should deal with is how exactly waivers will work next season. There are really only 2 options that ESPN allows, and we may want to switch this year.

Option 1:
Same as last year. Each week, the waiver order resets to the inverse of the current league standings. So the worst team in the league has the first waiver pick.

Reason For:
It helps the teams in last place get first dibs on the players on waivers, hopefully evening out the league.

Reason Against:
It de-values the waiver process by allowing each team to pick up as many players as they want without any real consequence for the next week, leading teams to pick up players they don't really need. In last year's case, Whitey had the best record in the league, but when players started getting injured, he was in no position to pick up anyone of value from waivers. Of course, that wasn't the only thing that led to his eventual demise.

Option 2:
Week 1, the waiver order is the inverse of the draft order (whoever drafted 12 would have the first waiver position, and so on). From there, when you pick up someone off of waivers, you move to the end. The only way to move up is for someone else to pick someone up off waivers, then that person becomes the 12 spot. So the waiver order does not reset each week.

Reason For:
It allows everyone at the very least a chance to get a nice waiver wire position, instead of penalizing the teams who do well. It makes people value their waiver wire pick-ups a little more because you know you'll be at the end for next week so you might not choose just to pick up someone you don't need one week in hopes of having a better chance at a player you may actually need the following week.

Reason Against:
Teams that have the worst record in the league aren't necessarily going to be in the best position to pick up players they need. Of course, this could lead to more trading, which would be interesting.

6 comments:

  1. Anonymous said...

    i'm more neutral on this debate...but if pressed for an answer, i'd say switch to the new method.  

  2. Strictly Fantasy said...

    I like the new method as well. I vote for #2.  

  3. John Herrington said...

    What about option #3, free-for-all waiver wire? Is it just not an ESPN option? I've seen other leagues do this which rewards those that are on top of what's going on.  

  4. Kelley said...

    #2 is how every fantasy baseball league I've ever played in has been, and its always worked and been deemed "Fair"...so I vote for that.  

  5. Hildee said...

    Yeah, I'm with Herrington. Option 3 would be the best. Those who do the leg work and are on top of things should be the one's rewarded. If this can't be done, then I'm for option 2.  

  6. Anonymous said...

    Option 3 is possible, but players will unlock between 2:15am-3am central time on tuesday morning...therefore we'll all have to wait up insanely late every monday night to do this...it really doesn't reward knowledge so much as late night endurance  


 

Copyright 2006| Blogger Templates by GeckoandFly modified and converted to Blogger Beta by Blogcrowds.
No part of the content or the blog may be reproduced without prior written permission.